RCMP ‘sitting on’ watchdog report into alleged spying on anti-oil protesters
By Jim Bronskill, The Canadian PressNews Public Sector civil liberties CRCC CSIS Environmental groups rcmp spying
OTTAWA—The RCMP has been sitting for two years on a watchdog report into alleged Mountie surveillance of anti-oil protesters, a civil liberties group charges.
In a letter this month to RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki, a lawyer for the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association laments the “inordinate delay” that has effectively obstructed the report’s release.
The association lodged a complaint in February 2014 with the Civilian Review and Complaints Commission for the RCMP. It alleged the national police force improperly collected and shared information about people and groups who peacefully opposed the planned Northern Gateway pipeline project and attended National Energy Board meetings.
The association said monitoring, surveillance and information sharing with other government agencies and the private sector created a chilling effect for those who might wish to take part in hearings or other public discussions on petroleum issues.
The commission launched a public interest investigation and completed an interim report into the matter in June 2017, forwarding it to the RCMP for comment on the conclusions and recommendations.
The commission cannot prepare a final report until the RCMP commissioner responds, which also means the findings can’t be disclosed to the civil liberties association or the public.
In March, Paul Champ, a lawyer for the association, wrote commission chairwoman Michelaine Lahaie to express concern that more than five years had passed since the complaint was filed, saying the RCMP may have violated the fundamental freedoms of Canadians exercising their democratic rights.
“It is our view that this interminable delay undermines the credibility of the CRCC and, more importantly, calls into question its ability to fulfil its primary function: ensuring accountability of the RCMP and fostering public trust and confidence in Canada’s national police force,” Champ’s letter said.
“It is regrettable that the CRCC may not be treating this complaint with the seriousness it deserves.”
After receiving no reply, he followed up with another letter in May.
Nika Joncas-Bourget, the commission’s director and general counsel for reviews, told Champ in late May the watchdog shared his frustration with the Mounties.
“We can assure you that we have repeatedly expressed concern to the RCMP regarding the time it is taking to receive the Commissioner’s Response,” she wrote.
Joncas-Bourget said once the commission receives Lucki’s response, it will “promptly issue” a final report, something it usually does within 30 days of getting the top Mountie’s input.
The RCMP acknowledged Wednesday there is a delay in responding to interim reports from the commission, due in part to the number of reports and the volume of relevant material to be analyzed. “Efforts are currently underway to address this imbalance.”
Maintaining public trust and confidence is critical to providing an effective police service, said Carlene Variyan, a spokeswoman for Public Safety Minister Ralph Goodale, the cabinet member responsible for the RCMP.
“We expect that all parties involved in this investigation fulfil their obligations without undue delay.”
In his Aug. 9 letter to Lucki, Champ noted the RCMP Act imposes a legal duty to provide a response to the commission’s interim report “as soon as feasible.”
“In short, the RCMP has been sitting on this report for over two years and effectively obstructing its release to my client and the public,” he wrote.
“It is our view that two years for your review and response to the CRCC’s interim report is clearly an unreasonable delay not contemplated by the statute, whether the delay is due to insufficient allocation of resources or any other cause.
“This delay is all the more serious when the allegations concern fundamental rights and freedoms protected by the Canadian Constitution.”
The civil liberties association also complained in early 2014 about improper monitoring of anti-pipeline activists by the Canadian Security Intelligence Service.
The review committee that oversees CSIS dismissed the complaint in 2017, prompting the association to ask the Federal Court to revisit the outcome, a proceeding that is ongoing.
News from © Canadian Press Enterprises Inc. 2019
Print this page